Hope Valley has seen its fair share of heartwarming moments, but one of the sweetest stories is happening off-screen. When Calls the Heart stars Erin Krakow (Elizabeth Thornton) and Ben Rosenbaum (Mike Hickam) have quietly captured fans’ hearts—not just through their characters, but through their blossoming real-life romance.
After months of speculation from fans and subtle social media hints, Erin and Ben confirmed their relationship in 2024, much to the delight of the Hearties community. Though their characters lead separate lives on the show, in reality, the pair has found a beautiful connection that continues to grow.
Are Erin Krakow and Ben Rosenbaum Still a Couple?
Yes, they are—and their relationship appears stronger than ever. While both actors prefer to keep their private lives relatively low-key, they’ve shared a few touching moments that confirm their bond.
On March 3, 2024, Erin celebrated Ben’s birthday with a heartfelt Instagram post. She praised him as someone who “takes such good care of us” and “makes the world laugh,” alongside a charming photo of Ben snuggling their beloved dog, Willoughby. The post melted hearts and reassured fans that the couple was very much still together.
Valentine’s Day also brought a rare glimpse into their romance. Erin shared a cozy photo of the two together, which drew praise and excitement from fans and fellow cast members alike. Kayla Wallace, another When Calls the Heart star, left a sweet comment expressing how happy she was to see them together.
When Did Their Relationship Begin?
The exact timeline of their romance remains a mystery, as Erin and Ben have chosen to keep the details private. However, rumors began circulating in early 2023. Erin posted a photo introducing their dog Willoughby, hinting at a shared life and close relationship with Ben.
By February 2024, their relationship was all but confirmed when Erin posted a loving Valentine’s Day message featuring a photo of her kissing Ben on the cheek. That moment officially made their love story public, and fans were thrilled.
Will Erin and Ben Return for When Calls the Heart Season 13?
Great news for fans—both Erin Krakow and Ben Rosenbaum will return for Season 13 of When Calls the Heart. Hallmark made the announcement during the Season 12 finale, confirming that the beloved drama will continue in 2026.
Season 12 ended on a dramatic note, with Elizabeth heading to Cape Fullerton to seek better medical care for her son, Little Jack, whose diabetes had taken a turn. Nathan and Allie joined her, creating a touching moment of unity and support.
Meanwhile, Mike Hickam and Mei gave up their honeymoon to help Elizabeth and Little Jack. In a heartwarming twist, the town rewarded their sacrifice with a surprise gift: a dream vacation to Miami. Fans can expect to see how these developments play out when the show returns.
A Love That Shines in Real Life
While it’s common for on-screen co-stars to spark dating rumors, few couples make the transition as seamlessly as Erin and Ben. Their relationship feels grounded in friendship, shared values, and a mutual love for storytelling—and their fans couldn’t be happier for them.
What makes their romance even more endearing is how naturally it has unfolded. They didn’t make a big announcement or seek the spotlight. Instead, their bond has grown quietly, supported by their work and the close-knit Hallmark community.
Why Don’t They Post Together Often?
Some fans have wondered if the couple is still together because they don’t frequently share photos online. But it turns out that Erin and Ben simply prefer to keep their relationship private and away from the public eye.
Their few public posts are enough to show their affection, and they’ve chosen to focus on their work and personal happiness rather than frequent social media appearances. It’s a refreshing reminder that not all love stories need to be public to be real and meaningful.
Final Thoughts: Love On and Off the Screen
As we wait for more adventures in Hope Valley, fans can take comfort in knowing that Erin Krakow and Ben Rosenbaum’s love is going strong behind the scenes. Their story adds another layer of warmth to the When Calls the Heart universe—and serves as a reminder that sometimes, the most beautiful romances are the ones that grow quietly and sincerely.
Stay tuned for more updates on Season 13, cast news, and behind-the-scenes insights. And if you’re a true Heartie, don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe to stay connected with the latest from your favorite stars.
Leave feedback about this